Looking back

We wrote 13 pitch lessons in 2014. Here is what held up.

We reread our own advice to founders from 2014 and checked it against what over 500 data rooms have shown us since. Most of it survived. Some of it we would not write again.

4 min read

In September 2014 we published the pitchXO Academy: thirteen short lessons on pitching, written in one week and sent out as a weekly mail. Then we left them alone for twelve years.

Since then over 500 companies have run a paid data room with us, and more than 20,000 readers have logged in to read their decks. So we reread the lessons, pulled out thirteen pieces of advice, and asked of each one: would we still say this?

13pieces of advice checked
8held up
4half right
1aged out

What held up

Held up
Start with the problem, not the product

The listener has to feel what is wrong before a solution means anything. Nothing about this has changed.

Held up
Start somewhere and talk about it

The 2014 lesson said the more you talk, the more feedback you get. The rooms say the same: in rooms still in use a year later, six in ten owners had sent invitations straight from the room. Most rooms that were given up never had a single reader.

Held up
Pitch early, pitch often

A deck with no readers teaches you nothing. A deck with ten readers tells you which slide people stop on.

Held up
Do not overload your slides

The typical long-running room holds two decks and about 35 slides in total. The decks that get read are small.

Held up
End on an executive summary

We saw it win over a jury in 2014. Since then the one-pager has become one of the three documents founders name again and again: teaser, one-pager, full deck.

Held up
Know what makes you different

The shortest lesson of the thirteen, and the one most decks still skip. It belongs near the front.

Held up
Do not talk down your competitors

Name them, say what they do well, say why a customer picks you. Insults only cost you.

Held up
Find investors through people you know

An introduction beats any list. It is also how rooms fill: the first readers are the five people who already said "send me the deck".

Try this with your own deck: start a 30-day trial. Your card is not charged during the trial.

Half right

Half right
Follow up, even twelve times

We wrote that a reply can take up to twelve mails. Persistence is right: readers of a typical long-running room show up in nine different months. The number was the wrong thing to count. Follow up when you have something to say, and say it: "I saw you spent time on the market slide" is a different mail from "just checking in".

Half right
Make your fundraising an event

Talking to investors in parallel, with an end date, is still sound. But reading does not stop on that date. People come back, forward the link and return before a second meeting. Plan the raise as an event and keep the room open after it.

Half right
Hunt down the investor's mail address

In 2014 we suggested tools that guess a private address from a name. The grit behind that is right: nobody hands you a raise. The direction is wrong. A mail out of nowhere is the weakest way in. Spend the same effort on getting a foot in the door somewhere else: a founder they backed, a mutual contact, an event where they speak. Connections over random mail.

Half right
Demo within 15 seconds

Right for a stage with a working product. A deck in a room is read alone, with nobody to click through a demo. There the rule becomes: show the product on one of the first slides, as a picture, before you explain it.

Connections over random mail.

Aged out

Aged out
Our list of websites and templates

Several of the sites and tools we recommended have closed or changed hands. Lists like that age within a year. The method behind them has not: research who invests at your stage and in your sector before you write to anyone.

One we argued about ourselves

The lessons said: open with a story about a person and their problem. In the same week we published a report from a pitch event where startup after startup opened with "Meet Jack", and after eleven pitches in two hours the audience was tired of Jack.

Both are true. Start with the problem, and tell it in your own way. If your opening could belong to any other startup in the room, it is not yours yet.

What we would add today

In 2014 we wrote about the stage. Most of a raise happens somewhere else: an investor alone with your deck, between two meetings.

Send a room, not an attachment

A PDF goes wherever it is forwarded. A room has a door, and you see who came in.

Read the report before you follow up

Which slides, how long, who came back. It turns a follow-up into a conversation.

Keep going after the round

The same room carries the monthly update. Investors already have the link.

The lessons themselves are still here, reworked into two guides: how to build and give the pitch and how to find investors and get a reply. And the event report that started the argument is in the archive.

Build your investor room

30 days free. Your card is not charged during the trial.